After Kashmiri Pandits, it's the turn of others
by Sandhya Jain on 10 Sep 2013 9 Comments

A clinical look at the sequence of rioting in Kishtwar since the targetted violence against the miniscule Pandit community and its forced exodus from the Kashmir valley in 1990 reveals a five-year cycle of aggression, viz., 1993, 1998, 2003, 2008, and now 2013, which can hardly be coincidental. The implication is grim: long term plans, most likely in concert with Pakistan’s Inter Services Intelligence (ISI), have been made for the ethnic cleansing of Kishtwar’s Hindu community, as a prelude to achieving a festering dream (read sore) called Greater Kashmir.

 

The scheduled exit of US troops from Afghanistan in 2014 has made the region extremely volatile, with a Pakistan determined to extend its influence on both frontiers pushing jihadis across the Indian side of the line of control to provide relief to the departing Americans. At the same time, the jihadi forces and their collaborators are exerting pressure on the Jammu and Kashmir Government to disarm and disband the village defence committees (VDCs) that have served as the vanguard of the defence of Jammu region since 1995 and provided a sense of security to the beleaguered Hindu community.

 

Union Minister Farooq Abdullah has jumped into the fray and informed the cabinet that the VDCs comprise of “communal” elements, thereby aggravating Hindu insecurity. The Congress state unit president Saifuddin Soz has also chipped in, calling for a review of the role of the VDCs.

 

Since the issue is critical to national security, it is imperative that the VDCs are maintained and strengthened, as militancy is expected to escalate steeply in coming months. Kishtwar district comprises 43 per cent Hindus and 57 per cent Muslims, but arms licenses have been issued in the ratio of 2:98, though it is well known that Hindus are the vulnerable community.

 

Strategic expert Maj Gen Gagandeep Bakshi (ret) points out that the Pakistan-Afghanistan border with its hundreds of madrassas is a global jihad factory. The economic collapse of the Soviet Union triggered the fall of the Najibullah regime, but gave Gen. Zia-ul Haq delusions of power and led him to intensify the proxy war in Jammu and Kashmir, via the Jamait-e-Islami. The ISI wanted the ethnic Dogra community to be ousted from this district, especially after terrorists were eliminated due to the vigilance of the village committees.

 

The first selective killing of Hindus in Jammu province took place in 1993, when 17 Hindus were identified and killed in Sarthal near Kishtwar. This set a trend that continued up to 2001; the VDCs were formed in response to these communal killings in remote areas that could not be defended by the army.

 

The current violence, say Hindus from Kishtwar who are visiting the capital to apprise Parliamentarians of their plight, was not an ordinary incident sparked off by some local irritant, but a disturbing instance of the Government of Jammu and Kashmir vs. state minorities (read Hindus). Nor was the violence spontaneous or unexpected, as suggested by the initial reports that appeared outside the State.

 

The region has been communally sensitive since the hanging of Afzal Guru in February this year. Just two days prior to Eid, the police entered several local mosques and removed posters of Hurriyat leader Shabir Shah with Afzal Guru and Maqbool Bhat, which called on Muslims to take to the streets. Far from strengthening security in the area, the then Minister of State for Home, Sajjad Ahmad Kitchloo, permitted similar posters of Maqbool Bhat, Afzal Guru and Shabir Shah to be plastered on the walls of his family home in the district.

 

As Kitchloo was present in the town throughout the incidents, locals hold him responsible for all that unfolded. Kitchloo kept the then Deputy Commissioner Chaudhary Saleem Mohammad, Senior Superintendent of Police Sunil Gupta and a 200-strong police force inactive at the Dak Bungalow while mayhem was unleashed from 10 am to 7.40 pm on August 9, Eid day. The Sashastra Seema Bal post in Kishtwar reportedly told the SIT appointed to probe the violence that they had specific orders not to intervene in the arson and looting.

 

An armoury owned by Kitchloo’s relatives was allowed to be looted by opening the iron gates (there is no evidence of the gates being forced open) and 35000 cartridges and 42 rifles were taken. So far, only 22 rifles have been recovered and 11 persons booked. The blatant nature of the violence – with shops and markets owned by Hindus reduced to ashes in minutes with no response from the police and administration – forced the Chief Minister to take Kitchloo’s resignation on August 12; the Deputy Commissioner and Senior Superintendent of Police were transferred within 24 hours.

 

But the State Government indulged in a misinformation campaign to keep Parliament and the Prime Minister in the dark regarding events in the district, and the Army could enter only at 7.40 pm. The people alleged that the administration transported miscreants outside the district.

 

Ostensibly, the violence began a little after 10 a.m. in the Hindu-dominated Kuleed Chowk area after a local BJP leader Sunil Sharma was returning home after bringing some emergency medicines for his family, and was stopped by a 1,500-strong procession headed for Eid prayers at the Chowgan ground. Eid processions have never taken this route in the past, but Hindus stoutly deny that this sparked off any incident.

 

Instead, they claim, the brahmin mohalla heard loudspeakers making objectionable calls, as a consequence of which Hindu shops and businesses were attacked with stones and petrol bombs. In all, over 100 shops and a similar number of private cars and other vehicles were reduced to a cinder by the time the Rashtriya Rifles’ units 11RR, 8RR and 17RR entered the town.


For years, rich and influential Muslims have been putting immense pressure on rich Hindu families to sell their properties in prime locations in the district to them, and move out. These properties were gutted in the recent violence with the intention of impoverishing and demoralizing the Hindu community.

 

Kishtwar residents demand that Jammu’s connectivity with Himachal Pradesh should be improved, a demand persistently been made by Ladakh, to give India a fighting chance to hold on to the region. If Hindus are expelled from Kishtwar, the road to Greater Kashmir will be clear. To save the State, India must strengthen the VDCs and provide them with sophisticated weapons in place of the obsolete 303 rifles.

The Pioneer, 10 September 2013 

User Comments Post a Comment
How much more scandalous it can get for Hindus in Hindusthan. What could be your take on trifurcation of J & K ? Will it help protect Hindus? [ what an irony,Hindus needing protection!].If we strengthen these new states of Jammu & Ladakh,can we tackle Jihadis in the valley more effectively?
What Hindus at large are doing for Hindus in Kishtwar?
Jitendra Desai
September 10, 2013
Report Abuse
So long as India is run by foreigners , today, an Italian housewife, tomorrow, a half Italian/half Indian , there cannot be a genuine help for what is Indian or Hindus / Buddhists etc, since only those foreigners & their catholic gods know where there loyalty is standing ? & who are there masters? are they working on an agenda of US/West to disintegrate India or not ?
Finally isn't it a shame for India with over 1.2 billion population to have somebody from outside India to run this country ?
Kumar
September 10, 2013
Report Abuse
On the similar note i here paste article Kishtwar Riots - The Beginning Of Ethnic Cleansing by By Lt Gen Raj Kadyan, September 2013
It can be read at http://www.esamskriti.com/essay-chapters/Kishtwar-Riots-~-The-Beginning-of-Ethnic-Cleansing-1.aspx

If the VDCs are disarmed or their capabilities degraded in way, the entire mountain population of Jammu province will be at grave risk. They may have no choice but to escape to the suburbs of Jammu like Pandits did. That would add to the problem, that Pakistan deliberately tries to create by targeting the civil population along the LoC and even the international border. Once a terrorized population abandons their homes, their return is impossible, just as it happened in the case of Pandits. All the talk of rehabilitating them back in their ancestral homes in the Valley is either naïve or dishonest. The facts on the ground once created can seldom be changed. No debates in Parliament and long speeches in New Delhi will be able to undo the migration. Saving Kishtwar means saving Jammu province and saving Jammu province means saving India. And the VDCs are the key to doing so.

The Author is former Deputy Chief of Army Staff
Courtesy and copyright www.indiandefencereview.com
Rashmi
September 11, 2013
Report Abuse
Editor – Hindus have a policy of live and let live, are not born with a desire that Sanatan Dharam should rule the world. Unlike them, Muslims are an aggressive proselytizing religion who wants to dominate public discourse esp. in countries where they are not in a majority. Every effort of theirs is directed towards controlling the public discourse, living by their religious laws, retaining a separate religious identity, owning land and constructions of mosques (Azaan 5 times a day) such that non-Muslims are always aware of their presence. Sri Aurobindo said ‘The Muslims, they want to rule India again’. This was said over sixty years ago. I can see it happening. Unfortunately, the Hindu is naïve and is unable to understand the sub-continental Muslim mind.
Rashmi
September 11, 2013
Report Abuse
Also read

1. Kashmiri Hindus: Can they return. For the first time Pandits speak their hearts out on what happened in 1990. Program was aired in January 2012 and had no Seculars amongst the speakers.

2. How many died in the Kashmiri Terrorist Movement

3. Why Secularism is not an Indian concept

4. Tackling scourge of terrorism in Kashmir, Congress-style

5. Arms seized from Kashmiri Militants

6. J&K – Oppressing a Free Press

7. Ladakhis demand freedom from India
Rashmi
September 11, 2013
Report Abuse
There were two prominent players involved in cleansing out Pandits from the Kashmir Valley. Syed Ali Shah Geelani was the Amir of Jamait-e-Islami which controlled the network of mosques in Srinagar. It was these mosques that broadcast the message 24 hours a day to terrorize the Pandits. The message as translated from Kashmiri was: “We do not want Pandits in Kashmir. We just want their women.” Its ominous import was unmistakable. Little wonder that Pandit families with young women were the first ones to run away. The other leader was Muhammad Yasin Malik who led his then underground group JKLF in carrying out selective target killing of prominent Pandits. This added to the terrorization and accelerated the exodus. The Hurriyat has cleverly kept a few Hindus and Sikhs for window dressing to give their ‘freedom struggle’ a façade of secularism. These minorities are intended to be kept safe only till the ‘freedom’ is attained and then they along with the Shia Muslims will meet the same fate as the Pandits. Kashmir Valley is envisaged to become a 100% Sunni fundamentalist State, another North Waziristan, whenever it suits Pakistan or its acolyte, the Hurriyat leaders.


The fact that the Hindus of erstwhile Doda District which includes Kishtwar did not meet the same fate is thanks only to one factor, the Village Defence Committees (VDC) that the threatened hamlets and villages formed. These were then armed and played a major role in preventing the exodus of Hinds from that district as also in keeping the Jammu province safe. No security force can provide protection to every family in isolated villages. VDCs did a commendable job in that role. They not only secured their villages, but also kept the ‘freedom struggle’ away from the Jammu province. That essentially kept the insurgency confined to the Kashmir Valley, despite Pakistan’s best efforts. Consequently, the VDC were the favourite target of the terrorists and their overground supporters and they lost many lives. Under pressure from what India calls separatists but essentially Pakistani agents, the politicians of the Valley have never been very sympathetic to the VDCs. Mufti Muhammad Saeed of PDP had in fact tried to disband them when he became the Chief Minister.
Rashmi
September 11, 2013
Report Abuse
To conclude -

Now the Hurriyat which had no presence south of the Valley, has made disbandment of VDCs a major issue in order, as it says, to remove the sense of insecurity among the Muslims of the area. That demand is obviously inspired by Pakistan whose every action since the beginning of this year points towards the revival of the ‘freedom Straggle’. The recent riots in Kishtwar have provided them a pretext to rake up the issue though no VDC had taken part in them. Being located in villages, VDCs were not even present in Kishtwar town. There was only one death by gunfire and the victim was one Arvind Kumar. Yet, the finger pointing at VDCs continues.

Though the VDCs are the responsibility of the State Govt, the Army has a vital stake in them. No Army can provide protection to every house and hamlet in the sparsely populated mountainous region. Nor can the Army block all the routes of ingress through Pir Panjal into Jammu province and that province will become vulnerable. Pir Panjal range also has major infiltration routes from Pakistan.

If the VDCs are disarmed or their capabilities degraded in way, the entire mountain population of Jammu province will be at grave risk. They may have no choice but to escape to the suburbs of Jammu like Pandits did. That would add to the problem, that Pakistan deliberately tries to create by targeting the civil population along the LoC and even the international border. Once a terrorized population abandons their homes, their return is impossible, just as it happened in the case of Pandits. All the talk of rehabilitating them back in their ancestral homes in the Valley is either naïve or dishonest. The facts on the ground once created can seldom be changed. No debates in Parliament and long speeches in New Delhi will be able to undo the migration. Saving Kishtwar means saving Jammu province and saving Jammu province means saving India. And the VDCs are the key to doing so.

The Author is former Deputy Chief of Army Staff.
Courtesy and copyright www.indiandefencereview.com
Rashmi
September 11, 2013
Report Abuse
A report titled “Kashmir: Present Situation and Future Prospects”, which was submitted to the European Parliament by Emma Nicholson, Baroness Nicholson of Winterbourne, was critical of the lack of human rights, justice, democracy, and Kashmiri representation in the Pakistan National Assembly.

According to the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, Pakistan’s Inter Services Intelligence operates in Pakistan-administered Kashmir and is involved in extensive surveillance, arbitrary arrests, torture, and murder.
Generally this is done with impunity and perpetrators go unpunished.

The 2008 report by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees determined that Pakistan-administered Kashmir was ‘NOT FREE’.

According to Shaukat Ali, chairman of the International Kashmir Alliance, “On one hand Pakistan claims to be the champion of the right of self-determination of the Kashmiri people, but she has denied the same rights under its controlled parts of Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan”
nitha
September 14, 2013
Report Abuse
PANUN KASHMIR
H.NO. 172,Sec 3,EWS Colony,
Lower Roop Nagar-13.
Tele 0191-2593166
PRESS RELEASE
• Panun Kashmir observes 24th Martyr’s Day( Kashmiri Hindu balidaan Diwas)
• Panun Kashmir says minorities in the state are in the cusp of the communal forces
• Panun Kashmir condemns Kishtwar violence
• Panun Kashmir says when genocide is neglected ,it duplicates
• Panun Kashmir reaffirms that Homeland with the Union territory status is the only solution to reverse the Kashmiri Pandit genocide and Holocaust.

Panun Kashmir today observed the 24th Martyr’s Day to pay rich tributes to all the Martyr’s of the Kashmiri Pandit community who were brutally killed by the Islamic communalists in Kashmir as it was on this day 24 years ago , the prominent Kashmiri Pandit leader and social activist Sh Tika Lal Taploo was assassinated by the Kashmiri Muslim separatists. Rich tributes were paid to security forces who have laid down their lives while upholding the territorial integrity and sovereignty of the Indian nation in frontline Indian state of Jammu and Kashmir and the victims of the Kishtwar who have recently faced persecution at the hands of the communal forces.
To introspect and analyse the challenges before the minorities of the Jammu and Kashmir and the threats to their survival and human rights Panun Kashmir organized a seminar on the eve of the Martyr’s Day(Kashmiri Pandit Balidaan Diwas) on the topic “ Battle of Survival against growing fundamentalism in J & K”
A galaxy of prominent socio-political and security experts participated in the seminar and expressed their views. Various speakers who expressed their opinions regarding the fragile security conditions and fate of minorities in the state included Dr.Ajay Chrungoo,Chairman,Panun Kashmir,Prof.(Dr)M.K.Teng, eminent political scientist and Chairman Advisory, Panun Kashmir, Prof.M.L. Kaul, renowned scholar and writer, Sh.M.M.Khajooria, retired DIG and security expert. Dr.K.L.Choudhary,eminent physician,writer and thinker, Sh.Shailendra Aima,Vice- Chairman,Panun Kashmir and eminent educationist.
While speaking on the occasion,Dr. Ajay Chrungoo said,”The state of Jammu and Kashmir is witnessing the consolidation of the regressive forces who are fed by the religious theo fascism meant to dismantle the edifice of the Indian nation in the state.The direct outcome of this evil machination is the targeting of the non Muslim minorities who are being subjected to the continuous holocaust and genocide. The recent violence in Kishtwar was outcome of the consolidation of the fanatic forces who are heel bent to religiously cleanse the minorities from their habitat so that the secular nation building is compromised to suit the separatist agenda of the exclusivist forces.”
Paying rich tributes to the Martyr’s of the Kashmiri Pandit community and the security forces who laid down their lives to uphold the civilisational values of the Indian nation,he said,” On the Martyr’s Day we pledge ourselves to remember what we were, what has happened to us and what we are.
Today we dedicate ourselves to Collective Memory as the highest value to be preserved and perpetuated so that we are able to improve our present and endeavor to create a new future without a sense of fear or failure.
All these years in exile we have stood up to the forces of exclusion and persecution. Despite odds we have pursued dignity, honour and excellence in exile. We have created a vision to reverse our exile completely and permanently.”
Reiterating the demand for the Homeland with the union territoty status,Dr.Chrungoo said,” It is now beyond doubt to everybody that Panun Kashmir is our politics. Struggle for reclaiming our homeland is the life blood of our survival. It has given us purpose in exile. It has given us respect in exile. It has forced the establishment to provide us sustenance in exile.
Panun Kashmir is a response to Jihad and fundamentalism of any nature. Panun Kashmir is a response to exclusivism. It is a response of a civilisation under assault to stand on its own. Panun Kashmir is a caution to the nation that if a genocide is ignored it only duplicates. The answer to the genocide of a community is not to ignore it or fudge it or trivialize it. The answer to genocide is to reverse it.”

Panun Kashmir is a clarion call to the nation of India to desist from abandoning its civilisational and political frontiers. Panun Kashmir is a movement to stop the nation state from the pursuit of compromises with communalism in the hope of peace.”
Expressing his expert opinion.Dr.M.K.Teng said,”Jammu and Kashmir is the civilisational bulwark of the Indian nation. We are in a state of perpetual war since the partition and what we are witnessing in J and K is the conspiracy to wrest the state from India in the garb of so called freedom struggle in the name of Islami and communal forces have waged war or jihad against the upholders of the Indian nation. The bitter truth is that Pakistan launched an offensive right from the time the partition plan was accepted to balkanize India and recommence the process of a second partition of India by seeking to support Muslim separatism in Jammu and Kashmir.”
Speaking on the human rights violation of the non Muslim minorities in J and K,Dr.teng said,” Four of the 10 million people living in Jammu and Kashmir on the Indian side of the Line of Control are Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists. They have as sacrosanct a right on every inch of their land as the six million Muslims have. They are not “bereft of souls”, they also have aspirations, feelings and memories of wrongs. They have been living in the enslavement of a situation created by Pakistan and those who seek freedom for J&K from “Indian occupation.The main agenda of the separatist forces and Pakistan is to open the way for Pakistan to reach the Shivalik plains situated to the west of the river Ravi in the south and the Sanskrit Himalayas in the north. It is a continuous process of the De –Sanskritisation of the Himalayas to dismantle the Northern Frontiers and demolish the Indian nation.”
Prof.M.L.Kaul said,” we are being subjected to communal onslaught and held under siege so that our lifelines are choked and a situation is created like 1990 when the state apparatus failed to safeguard the minorities in Kashmir and religious cleansing was inflicted on the Kashmiri Pandit community,basically its seeds were sown in 1931 when a non state subject Abdul Qadeer from the Frontier region instigated the rebellion and sedition and invoking the majority community of Kashmir to take revenge by persecuting the Hindus of Kashmir and the rest is history.
Our lands ,our habitat has been snatched and we have been rendered homeless foe being the upholders of the ancient Sanskrit civilisation as it acted as the road block for the Semitic religion that thrives on persecution and holocaust of the infidels. The need is to identify the enemy and call spade a spade.”

Sh.M .M.Khajooria said,” We are in a peculiar state as far as the security scenario is concerned.We are witnessing the symptoms of the situation that will unfold when the US forces will exit from the Af-Pak region.The recent spurt in the targeting and killing of the security forces in Kashmir besides infiltration from across the border should make the policy makers wake up and devise the mechanism that nips the evil in the bud.The secessionist forces are getting activated due to the active support of the ISI and Pakistani establishment who are diverting the terrorists into the conflict zone of Jammu and Kashmir to up the ante and shift the focus from the fragile Pakistani locale into this state.There is threat to the security and well being of the nationalist people in Kashmir as has been witnessed recently.Pakistan is working in tandem with its all weather friend China to violate the territorial integrity of India.”
Dr.K.L.Choudhary said,” the social structure of the valley has witnessed tremendous transformation and the radicalization has become the cardinal principle to propagate the communal politics meant to threaten and erase the human and cultural values.The recent incidents of coercion of the minority communities brings to the fore the ruptured social structure. There is no space for the freedom of human and cultural values that are hall marks of the progressive human societies. The minorities in the state have been rendered hostages of the communal forces at the cost of the democracy and secularism.”
Sh.Shailendra Aima said,” we are witnessing a serious challenge to the democratic values as enshrined in the Indian constitution. Secessionist forces are posing a grave challenge to the secular nation building in J and K by subjecting the minorities to gross human rights violations in terms of their right to life and dignity. Subjecting the original inhabitants to genocide and holocaust has become the underlying principle of the communal forces to shrink the nationalist space.There is a premium on separatism and humiliation for Indian nationalism in J & K .Himalaya is in the cusp of the forces who want to dismantle the frontiers of India and the minorities in J and K being the anchors of the Civilisational continuity of the India nation are bearing the brunt of the Islamic jihad and the Chinese imperialism. Indian state is in conflict with the Indian nation and the Indian civilization that has Sanskrit moorings.”
The seminar was ably conducted by Sh.Pyare Lal Raina,well known social activist and educationist from TRT,Muthi.
Sd/-
M.K.Dhar,
Secretary Press,
9906084385
M K Dhar
September 15, 2013
Report Abuse