So who is the Real Winner in Afghanistan?
by Valery Kulikov on 25 Sep 2021 6 Comments

The events in Afghanistan has grabbed the world’s attention as the observers try to project not only the country’s future path, but also to determine the role main foreign actors on the world’s chessboard played in this process while seeking to answer the main question: “Who is the real winner in Afghanistan?”

 

By all means, the answer to this question cannot be found solely by going through regional media’s coverage of the events that ensued in the first nine days between the fall of the Afghan provincial capital on 6 August and the capture of Kabul on August 15. Neither does it explain how Afghan troops, well-equipped and trained by the US, just vanished into thin air in the face of Taliban guerillas (outlawed in Russia), wearing sneakers and armed, to put it mildly, with not state-of-the art equipment.

 

Nevertheless the shocking fall of Kabul showcased the fact that the United States is on the back foot, and this process has spread to Asia and Africa entailing serious geopolitical ramifications for America’s global power. It has become increasingly obvious that Taliban’s victory is objectively pushing Washington out of Central Asia which will benefit China in terms of securing control over several parts of this strategically vital region, a home to 70% of world population and production.

 

While assessing US operations in Afghanistan it is worth remembering the remarkable comments of a prominent Russian orientalist and the Academic Director of Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences Vitaly Naumkin, who in exclusive interview with Asharq Al-Awsat recalled a statement by the US president Joe Biden saying:

“Our mission in Afghanistan was never supposed to be nation building. It was never supposed to be creating a unified, centralized democracy. Our only vital national interest in Afghanistan remains today what it has always been: Preventing a terrorist attack on American homeland.”

 

In other words, since the very beginning of the 20-year chaos in Afghanistan that the US military brought upon millions of Afghan people who relied on America to create a new democratic state the latter were left high and dry! So how can anyone speak about US victory in Afghanistan?

 

But China did not achieve its victory in Afghanistan overnight; it was a result of a precise and balanced policy of the “Silk Road Economic belt” announced by President Xi Jinping back in 2013 which has already started to expand the space for development of all Eurasian states through infrastructure that would connect the Pacific Ocean with the Baltic Sea while creating a major market possessing an unprecedented potential.

 

Over the past eight years, China has spent more than a trillion dollars on its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) to build a transcontinental network of railroads, oil pipelines and industrial infrastructure with the purpose of becoming the world’s most prominent economic power. As Beijing successfully built infrastructure along northern, eastern and western Afghan borders, it also set the stage for this war-torn country, now free from US influence and rife with untapped mineral resources (estimated at one trillion dollars), to fall into its lap without a single shot.

 

While Washington was spending billions to sow chaos, Beijing launched a gas pipeline “Central Asia-China” in the north of Afghanistan which will eventually run for 6,500 kilometers through the heart of Eurasia. That was possible due to cooperation of the Chinese National Petroleum Corporation with Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan. Beijing also spent $46 billion to construct the “China-Pakistan Economic Corridor”, a framework of roads, railways, pipelines stretching for more than 3,000 km along the eastern Afghan border from the western Chinese provinces to the Pakistani commercial port of Gwadar, now modernized by China.

 

Considering all this Taliban may strike lucrative deals on the extraction of enormous rare mineral reserves with China even today. Even just these advantages stemming from cooperation with China may allow Afghanistan to ban opium production, now a booming industry in this country. Moreover, a spokesperson of the new Taliban government has already pledged to do so.

 

Therefore, it is no wonder that Taliban spokesperson Zabihullah Mujahid called China the “principal partner” of the new Afghanistan on the global stage while Beijing reiterated its commitment to “invest and rebuild” Afghanistan. A statement to this effect has become the strongest signal yet of diplomatic priorities of Taliban as well as its plans to solve the economic crisis hurting Afghanistan.

 

Assessing the prospects of cooperation between the Taliban and foreign powers Mohammad Akbar Agha, a former Taliban field commander and now the leader of Afghanistan’s High Council of Salvation, said on 5 September that the new Afghan authorities are quite interested in establishing relations with Russia, Iran and Pakistan since they enjoy close ties with China.

 

Qatar is another undisputed winner in Afghanistan. This small Persian Gulf state was instrumental to solving the Afghan crisis of the past two decades. Making consistent steps and acting as a mediator between Taliban and the international community, Qatar managed to enhance its global and regional footprint and became one of the most valuable partners to have for many countries. In 2020 Qatar became the venue where Washington and the Taliban cut a historic deal on the US military withdrawal from Afghanistan. Doha sends tons of food, medicines, and various humanitarian supplies to this country.

 

While two-thirds of all those evacuated to Doha moved to other countries, Qatar is still housing about 20 thousand Afghan refugees. The Qatari authorities provide them with food and medical care; some Afghans have even been placed in villas originally built for the World Cup.

 

Doha has become not only the main transit point for evacuees from Afghanistan, but also a haven for Western embassies leaving Kabul. Now this city is a cluster of many foreign embassies (US, UK, Italy, Japan and other countries) but is also the center of all diplomatic activities in Kabul. Western diplomats and politicians have become frequent visitors to Doha. In August, the head of the German Foreign Ministry Heiko Maas flew to this place, while in early September Doha received the UK foreign secretary and Dutch and Italian foreign ministers.

 

On September 12 in Kabul, Taliban leaders (outlawed in Russia) agreed with Mohammed bin Abdul Rahman Al Thani, the Qatar’s Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister, on the further development of relations. A statement to this effect was published on the Twitter page of the Mohammad Naim, a spokesperson for Taliban’s political office.

 

While it is unclear what influence Qatar has on the Taliban and whether it will be able to adjust its course, this country remains the bridge between Taliban and the international community. No doubt, however, that the future hinges on the further development in Afghanistan.

 

Afghan crisis brought up Qatar to the top-tier club of international politics making the Persian Gulf state a valuable and welcomed friend. This is certainly extremely important for this regional power which has only recently emerged from regional isolation.

 

Valery Kulikov, expert politologist, exclusively for the online magazine “New Eastern Outlook”. Courtesy

https://journal-neo.org/2021/09/20/so-who-is-the-real-winner-in-afghanistan/ 

User Comments Post a Comment
Two lessons:
1. One reaps what one sows.
2. US is not to be trusted for developing your country; their interest is only in safeguarding their interests.
Raghu
September 25, 2021
Report Abuse
.....for one i can say with certainty , "India was the biggest loser" in this affair!
observer
September 25, 2021
Report Abuse
This article is too polyannish in its arguments. The Taliban will promise and promise, but will not keep its promises. It will most likely not ban the opium trade, although it will keep one of its promises, made by one of its leaders : public executions and cutting off hands !

The US has shifted its attention to the Indo Pacific. Russia is not fully agreeable to the rise of Islamic fundamentalism since it threatens its borders, and the republics of the former soviet union. China also will regret its closeness since there are the problems with the Ughirs etc.

Aukus and the other alliance in the Indo Pacific are here to stay(Quad). India is showing it can push back China, unlike during the Nehruvian years. Since the withdrawal of its troops from Afghanistan the US need not indulge and humour Pakistan, since it does not have to worry about transit routes.

Mr. Modi has cemented the relationship with the US which will mean billions of dollars of investment, both ways. Thousands of Indian students are going to the US, only a small fraction from Pakistan by contrast.

The world has changed considerably. China can no longer aspire to be the world's single super power.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
September 25, 2021
Report Abuse
...... even Biden snubbed modi on human rights and democratic issues, so much for the "QUAD" allies....seems like India is becoming "Pakistan 2.0", the most allied ally of US at point in history !
And when time came for help they were left high and dry , time to ponder ,indians (read modi's followers) !
observer
September 26, 2021
Report Abuse
Indian nationalism is alive and well. No danger of becoming hostage to US policies. Biden spoke about equal partnership with India, a term the US did not use either with Afghanistan or Pakistan. He also spoke about shared values, including human rights.

Mr. Modi himself at that remarkable speech at UNGA referred to India's diversity.

All in all, a successful trip and the warnings to Pakistan to stop being a haven for terrorists. Otherwise no one would be concerned with a small country like Pakistan. Once it mends its ways, the international community and that includes India.

Unfortunately, Pakistan's pathological enmity towards India seems to be persisting. Ofcourse, if it continues to encourage Taliban and is subservenient to China's expansionism, then the world will continue to shun it.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
September 26, 2021
Report Abuse
Modi's ONLY agenda is Anti-Muslim (or anti minorities in general) ,he won the elections (both times) by its anti Pakistan (read Muslim) rhetoric and that's all he has got, under him India has been in a tail spin towards earth, be it economically or politically.
Thanks to Pakistani PM Khan world is now totally aware of the Global Hindutva menace created and propagated by the Indian PM aka butcher of Gujarat who is a staunch follower and member of RSS terrorist organization who not only have the blood of Thousands of Gujarati and IOK Muslims but also the blood of Mahatama Gandhi who was the "pehchan" of secular India.
It is very encouraging to see the world is waking up to this new Nazi like goverenment in Sub continent.
observer
September 26, 2021
Report Abuse